NSW Selective Writing Feedback: Who Can Mark Your Child's Practice?

Four ways to get feedback on NSW Selective Writing practice, what each is good for, and why a "score out of 25" from an app is not an official mark.

3 min read By PrepKit

The short answer

  1. You have four options for feedback on practice writing: yourself, a teacher or tutor, an AI marker, or a mix. A mix gives fast feedback most weeks and a second opinion now and then.
  2. The Department says what the Writing test assesses, but it publishes no mark scheme or mark totals. Any practice score, ours included, is that provider's own scale.
  3. In the real test, two examiners mark each response, and a third marks it if their scores differ.
  4. Good feedback names one or two things to change next time. A number alone does not help a child write better.

Reading, maths and thinking questions mark themselves. Writing does not, so it is the hardest section to get feedback on at home. This page covers who can mark practice writing and what to expect from each. For how to run practice at home, see how to help your child with the Selective Writing test.

What the real test is looking for

The NSW Department of Education says the test "assesses the creativity of the student's ideas and their ability to write effectively for a purpose and audience". Your child plans on paper or on screen, then types the response. The Department also says each response "is marked by 2 different examiners", with a third marker if their scores differ.

A "score out of 25" is not an official mark

You will see practice scores out of 25 or 50, often split into two sets of criteria. The Department publishes no mark scheme or mark totals, so we could not find an official source for these numbers. Treat any practice score, including PrepKit's, as that provider's own scale. It can show whether your child is improving on that scale. It cannot tell you what they would get on the day.

Four ways to get feedback

Who marks itGood forWatch out for
You, reading it back togetherFree. Children hear where a sentence does not work. Good for ideas and clarity.Hard to stay calm and neutral, and easy to start rewriting it for them.
A teacher or tutorA person who knows your child and can spot patterns over time.Usually costs the most. Feedback may take days, when the writing is no longer fresh.
An AI marker in a practice appFeedback in minutes, so your child can fix it straight away. Low cost, and available for every practice.It can miss what a person would notice, and it can praise writing too easily. Read a few reports yourself.
A mixAI feedback most weeks, and a person now and then to check it agrees.Takes a little organising.

What good feedback looks like

It quotes the writing, gives one or two next steps, and looks at ideas before spelling. "Your second paragraph repeats the first" helps. "Good structure" does not.

How to test an AI marker

Before you rely on one, try this. Give it a strong piece and a weak piece from your child. Good feedback tells them apart and gives different advice for each. Then read the advice. If it would fit any piece of writing, it will not help your child much.

What PrepKit does

PrepKit has timed Writing prompts for the Selective test, typed on screen. AI marks each response against our own criteria, which are not the Department's, and gives feedback on each criterion and one top tip, up to 50 a week. It is part of full access, not the free questions, and only AI marks it, with no person checking. If you want a person involved, our comparison of practice options shows who offers what.